Concert Reviews | CD Reviews | DVD Reviews | Opera | Early Music | News | Film | Art | Books | Kids

27.2.06

Wiener Klaviertrio, Shriver Hall

Vienna Piano TrioThe Vienna Piano Trio was the latest group to play in the extraordinary 40th anniversary season at Shriver Hall, and so I found myself compelled to drive up to Baltimore Sunday night to hear them. After all, it's only a few minutes more in the car to get to Johns Hopkins than it was to get to Meredith Monk at George Mason. They brought an attractive program (.PDF file), too, a slice of their namesake city over about a century, beginning with Mozart and ending with Schoenberg, by way of Schubert. In response, Shriver Hall was nearly full with spectators, who heard some extraordinary playing.

First was the earliest, the B-flat trio, K. 502, one of two that Mozart composed in 1786. This work is mostly a showcase for the pianist, who begins each movement by himself and has the lion's share of the challenging music, and Stefan Mendl did a fine job on this part, which at times sounds like a sketch for one of Mozart's piano concerti. In spite of an annoying plinking timbre in the piano (heard only when the una corde pedal is depressed, a condition a technician might be able to correct), Mendl gave a beautiful, understated reading, all melody and Rococo filigree. The other musicians added to the generally restrained, elegant performance in their largely supportive roles. I was pleased to hear the happy first theme, tinged with minor mode shading in the consequent phrases, several times in the monothematic first movement, played with the repeat of the exposition.

Also on Ionarts:

Jens F. Laurson, Vienna Piano Trio at the National Gallery of Art (March 10, 2004)
The highlight of the concert concluded the second half, Arnold Schoenberg's Verklärte Nacht (Transfigured Night, 1899), an early work for string sextet, here in a winning arrangement for piano trio by Eduard Steuermann. It's a program work, a musical description of the late-night walk and conversation of the man and woman in Richard Dehmel's poem Zwei Menschen (Two people) [another translation] from a collection called Weib und Welt (Woman and world). Schoenberg finished the piece in a few weeks, while on vacation with his friend and composition teacher Alexander von Zemlinsky and Zemlinsky's sister Mathilde, the future Frau Schoenberg. It is a radiant work, making it hard to believe that it caused a minor riot at its premiere. (Gustav Mahler was impressed when he heard it for the first time.) Now it does not seem any more radical than Richard Strauss.

The piano trio arrangement, which the group played two years ago when Jens reviewed them at the National Gallery, puts emphasis on the main violin and cello parts of the piece, condensing most of the middle texture of Schoenberg's original into the piano part. In a most striking way, however, the Vienna Piano Trio brought more color and subtlety to the work than could have been imagined, setting the steady walking music of the opening in a heavy, hushed character, with muted, almost reedy sounds from cellist Matthias Gredler and violinist Wolfgang Redik. Mendl's piano shimmered in the moonlight of its lovely, soft tremolos, and the players brought such intelligence and Romantic sweep to the sometimes frenetic sounds of the woman's confession (she tells the man she has just fallen in love with that she is already pregnant with another man's child).
Just see how brightly the universe is gleaming!
There’s a glow around everything;
You are floating with me on a cold ocean,
But a special warmth flickers
From you into me, from me into you.
As the section ends on somber minor chords, we expect the worst, but the man insists that the night will transfigure the child, making it his own. Schoenberg takes us into a major tonality, corrupted with Wagnerian extended harmony and harplike textures under a soaring violin melody. The couple starts to walk again, as the opening music returns. Judging from the reactions I heard among members of the audience, the Vienna Piano Trio converted several people to Schoenberg's cause, at least as far as his early works are concerned. Having loved this work in its original sextet form and the composer's own arrangement for chamber orchestra, I was predisposed to like the piano trio arrangement, and I certainly did.

Other Reviews:

Tim Smith, Vienna Piano Trio (Baltimore Sun, February 28, scroll down to the bottom)
In a way it was greedy to think that the concert's final piece, Schubert's E-flat major trio, D. 929, could be as good, but it nearly was, up until the last movement. I will put this into context by recalling an excellent performance of this piece by the Beaux Arts Trio, which Jens and I reviewed in October. The Vienna Piano Trio's performance opposed two characters, a daring, heroic Schubert and a wavering, introspective one. After a first half that was all about transcendence and restraint, the players finally cut loose. Again, it was pianist Stefan Mendl who got the workout, beautifully navigating the triplets and whirring sixteenth note arabesques of the first movement. The second movement was decidedly more con moto than the stately Beaux Arts performance, but cellist Matthias Gredler was too reticent with its famous melody. By the fourth movement, with its tricky repeated-note triplets at such a fast tempo as the Vienna Piano Trio drove itself to, the pianist's fatigue finally showed (the group had played on Friday and Saturday evening, in Boston and Long Island, respectively), in a few dropped notes here and there. The returns of the second movement's melody seemed rushed and without the necessary impact, but the overall impact was still impressive, a fine ending to an excellent concert. In perhaps another sign of exhaustion, the group decided against playing an encore to reward the audience's approving applause.

The Vienna Piano Trio will continue its tour of the United States through March 6. The next event at Shriver Hall is a highly anticipated concert by Jordi Savall with Hesperion XXI (March 19, 5:30 pm). Ionarts will certainly be there.

5 comments:

Mark said...

We like it when you big city critics spend money here.

Charles T. Downey said...

I meant to call you to see if you wanted to meet me there, but I know your weekends are usually pretty loaded.

jfl said...

"...but I know on weekends you are usually pretty loaded"??? :) We read betweeb the lines, you know!

Charles T. Downey said...

I meant in addition to all of the heavy drinking, Jens. ;-)

Mark said...

hic