J.Haydn, SQ4ts Opp.64/5,76/2,77/1,
Jerusalem String Quartet
D.Shostakovich, SQ4ts Nos.1,4,6,8,9,11,
Jerusalem String Quartet
Harmonia Mundi Gold
In contrast to those endeavors, the Haydn in concert was certainly not perfect, something I'd only expect from the Emerson (performing next Thursday at Strathmore, where Ionarts will hear them) in any case. It did have some vitality, though—one of the most important elements in Haydn. The "Sunrise" theme was lyrically phrased, although better intonation would not have hurt. The Andante came with beautiful and melodic touches; the Menuetto: Allegro was a tad heavy-handed. The Finale: Allegro ma non troppo was brisk and almost exciting.
I love my Haydn, but it's the DSCH that I was most looking forward to, especially since live performances of his quartets are few and far between. From the motoric opening notes, presented first on the violin, then viola, and the following—almost conjured—sounds from the cello to this Andante's faint, surprising end, it was an arresting performance, far better than the Haydn quartet in all respects. The Allegretto furioso, too, was marvelous, though even more furiosity would have been possible. The violins' assault and driving rhythm was masterful, and once the Jerusalem Quartet found their groove, they left me wanting in nothing. Plenty of fury had accumulated by that point, and even Shostakovich neophytes ought to have been convinced and converted by the irresistible propulsion. The following Adagio exudes yearning calm. If one's ears were open during the preceding movement, the Adagio appears as sweet beauty, as lyrical passion. Standing alone it might be considered a sharply dissonant thing. (One reason why putting movements in the context of their works, rather than isolating them for, say, air-play, is so important.)
Beauty is not the aim of many works in music, from certain phrases in Haydn and Vivaldi to parts in Beethoven to entire works by the likes of Mahler (his 6th symphony, for example). It certainly was not a priority in most of Shostakovich's work, either. But the sincerity of his expression, the truth of his music, and the exemplary craftsmanship ensure that beauty is never far away. For example, in the deliciously plucked pizzicato passage of the fourth movement, Allegretto, where the viola plays the melody to an infectious rhythmic current that should have made you move and wiggle in your seat. The Jerusalem Quartet's performance, and I say this not only because I love the repertoire, was riveting throughout the entire piece. Da Capo, as far as I was concerned. (For a view that saw similarly little of the Haydn but the DSCH only "half-way there," read Gail Wein's review in the Washington Post.)
Dvořák's "American" quartet (nothing American about it, of course) is so popular in this country because of its nickname but should be just as popular on its musical merits alone. The four young musicians' interpretation was full of idiosyncratic little touches, aggressive and a little thin here, fat and bold there; not my favorite way to hear it, but a good deal better than the Haydn. Cellist Kyril Zlotnikov's contribution was particularly pleasing, but what was lacking is the natural touch that the Pražák or Chilingirian Quartets bring to Dvořák. Beautiful as certain phrases were, they also sounded self-conscious on several occasions.
In the Finale: Vivace ma non troppo the foursome bravely ignored the ma non troppo part and played the heck out of the music. While it only underscored the mentioned caveats regarding their performance, I also found myself enjoying the different approach of an oft-heard piece. It's not an interpretation that might please in repeated hearings on disc, but its impact in a one-time live performance turned out to be very entertaining. The audience, predictably, loved it and coaxed an encore (Haydn's finale from quartet op. 76, no. 6) out of the group. (Did no one tell them that standing ovations are meaningless in North America?) The encore was driven by speed demons, Haydn via Shostakovich.
Altogether, the recital—thanks to Shostakovich—was a worthy cap on this season's Kennedy Center Fortas Chamber Music Concerts series and a good argument to subscribe for what is coming in 2005–2006, e.g., Peter Serkin, the Guarneri SQ4t, the Kalichstein-Laredo-Robinson Trio, and Trio Mediaeval.