CD Reviews | CTD (Briefly Noted) | JFL (Dip Your Ears) | DVD Reviews

4.5.12

BSO and the Leningrad's Slow Burn

available at Amazon
Shostakovich, Symphony No. 7, St. Petersburg Philharmonic, Y. Temirkanov
(2010, Signum Classics)

available at Amazon
Ravel, Piano Concerto for the Left Hand (inter alia), L. Fleisher, Baltimore Symphony Orchestra, S. Comissiona
(Vanguard Classics)
Not much about the last few years of Marin Alsop's tenure at the Baltimore Symphony Orchestra -- nor her plans for next season -- has left me all that excited. So it is an extraordinary pleasure -- no one likes to spend so much time being negative -- to relay the most favorable impression of this week's program from Alsop and the BSO, heard last night in Baltimore's Meyerhoff Symphony Hall. Now it is true that this concert opened with another example, far too frequent, of recapitulation in Alsop's programming. Ravel's Piano Concerto in D Major, for left-handed pianist Paul Wittgenstein, was last heard from the BSO only two years ago, with James Gaffigan conducting Christopher O'Riley at the keyboard.

The soloist this time, though, was local legend Leon Fleisher, now in his 80s, returning to a piece he had performed with so much authority in the phase of his career when he had lost most of the use of his right hand. Even Fleisher's charismatic presence -- cheers from the balcony greeted his entrance, evidence of some students in attendance (but not enough) -- could not fill this (all too often) partly empty hall. The somber opening of low brass and contrabassoon was played in all of its subtly vivid color, with Fleisher producing a poetic phrasing in his opening solo section, perhaps not as technically sure-handed as in his younger days but musically more formidable, and a smoky, jazz-inflected sheen to the second solo section, with more beautiful woodwind solos in the orchestra. In the grotesque march of the middle section -- a nice programming alternative to the same composer's Boléro, often said to be the inspiration for the march in the first movement of the other work on this concert, Shostakovich's seventh symphony -- the BSO lagged just slightly behind Fleisher's pace.

Dmitry Shostakovich began his seventh symphony in the month or so after learning that Germany had invaded the U.S.S.R., in June 1941, completing it later in the year after being evacuated from St. Petersburg. It was a sincerely patriotic period for Shostakovich, who volunteered for the army (he was not accepted) and worked with the citizen corps ready to put out fires on the roof of the St. Petersburg Conservatory, although scholar Laurel Fay notes that most of his colleagues devised reasons to keep Shostakovich from any real danger. Along with settings of Soviet songs, the seventh symphony was the best way for the composer to express his patriotic fervor: "I wrote the seventh symphony quickly," Fay records him saying. "I couldn't not write it. War was all around. I had to be together with the people, I wanted to create the image of our embattled country, to engrave it in music."

Remaining in the city after the German shelling had begun, Shostakovich played in benefit concerts and gave radio and newspaper interviews, and the story of the courageous young composer was instant gold for the Soviet regime. As Fay says of the seventh symphony, "it was a heady propaganda weapon, evoking both inspiration and defiance, and its publicity was exploited skillfully almost from the moment of the work's conception." He spent the worst part of the siege of Leningrad as a refugee in Moscow and farther east: he learned of the rampant hunger in the city, for example, from the news that his dog, like most animals in the city, had been eaten. Is the piece to be understood as a patriotic Soviet response to war, or are we to take at face value the composer's later positioning of the work as a condemnation of totalitarianism? Fay sees evidence of both interpretations in the composer's mind: he openly acknowledged at the time that the work was a response to the German invasion, but he also resisted suggestions that the finale could be strengthened by adding a chorus extolling the praise of Stalin.


Other Articles:

Tim Smith, Magnetic performances from Marin Alsop, Leon Fleisher, Baltimore Symphony (Baltimore Sun, May 4)
This was a courageous bit of programming on Alsop's part, since the last time the BSO performed the work was in 2001, under her predecessor, Yuri Temirkanov. This is not a comparison one would expect to be advantageous to Alsop, but she came up with gold for the daring, leading a performance that was a measured, earth-shattering slow burn. In pacing, it was not unlike Yuri Temirkanov's most recent recording, made live with the St. Petersburg Philharmonic (not the one made with the same orchestra in the 1990s, for RCA), an account that is alternately blistering and indulgent of the work's occasionally bathetic cinematic spectacle. The playing was all fine: a halo of string sound, especially radiant in the violins, plus luscious violas in the elegiac slow movement; woodwind solos all fragile (flute and piccolo), lyrical (oboe), melancholy (bassoon), and appropriately shrill (E-flat clarinet); galvanized, square-on brass choir (eight horns, six trumpets, six trombones, and tuba!); with only that final layer of machine-like precision missing in the snare drum part, and only at times. Alsop conducted with confidence, the fast tempos not too fast and the slow movement not too slow, for an overall timing that came in a few minutes longer even than Temirkanov but that never dragged.

This program will be repeated in its entirety only on Sunday (May 6, 3 pm) at the Meyerhoff, with versions of the lecture-performance "Off the Cuff" concerts scheduled for Friday (May 4, 8:15 pm) at Strathmore and Saturday (May 5, 7 pm) at the Meyerhoff.

SVILUPPO:
A few days after this concert, I learned that Leon Fleisher had attended his ex-wife's funeral service on Thursday afternoon, before proceeding to play this concert with the BSO that evening. Rikki Fleisher, who was divorced from Leon Fleisher in 1975, had died two days earlier of breast cancer.

Dip Your Ears, No. 117 (Rzewski's The People United)

available at Amazon
F.Rzewski, The People United Will Never Be Defeated!, Winnsboro Cotton Mill Blues,
Ralph van Raat
Naxos

Greatness in art usually transcends politics. Shostakovich’s appeal extends beyond communists; Diego Rivera and Pablo Neruda aren’t only admired by socialists; Leni Riefenstahl has been (quietly) admired and copied, and even the quality of Arno Breker’s work can be acknowledged without raising too many eyebrows, these days. The intended (or unintended) political message takes a distant second place to the artistic quality with which it is conveyed. Certain Frederic Rzewski knew that, and while his own politics then (and perhaps still today) favored the ‘well-meaning’ brand of totalitarianism, he studied Wagner to learn how to achieve maximum narrative effect. Rzewski’s music—“19th century grandeur with 20th century compositional techniques” as Ralph van Raat calls them—deserves to be whole-heartedly embraced.

“The People United Will Never Be Defeated! – 36 Variations on ¡El Pueblo Unido Jamás Será Vencido!” tells rather innocuously of the universally valid ‘human struggle for change’, in this case the struggle to resist the perfectly undemocratic forces hard at work to unseat the almost-democratic Salvador Allende. The theme for the Variation comes from Sergio Ortega who wrote the anthem of the same name to a pop-tune he picked up at the time. Rzewski’s hour-long treatment for piano takes this tune as its ever-recurring kernel and goes far and wide with it.

Unfortunately Naxos’s new recording with Ralph van Raat performing gives only one track for the theme and its 36 variations that vary so greatly from the aggressively abbreviated, to the fractured and dispersed, to dreamy tinkles of beauty casually scattered about like flower petals. Even the piano lid gets slammed. Given their similar politics, could it be that Rzewki was familiar with Marc Blitzstein’s 1920’s Piano Percussion Music that asks the same of the performer?

The fourth of the Four North American Ballads—the Winnsboro Cotton Mill Blues (background video here)—works up a storm that is totally irresistible before dropping some of that intensity for the lyrical, bluesy beginning of the second part. Van Raat goes far in that overwhelming direction and in some ways further than the composer. But he still remains surprisingly earthbound. Even Marc-André Hamelin, with his more accentuated, machine-like attack and Hyperion’s slightly better recorded piano sound, doesn’t come close to unleashing the fury that the repetition-and-increase can unfold live… like I last heard—with awe—in Severin von Eckardstein’s 2005 recital at the Kennedy Center.

The authentic struggle of Rzewski himself in this music is gripping; the ridiculous ease and devastating precision (almost beyond what the score indicates) with which Hamelin cruises through them breathtaking—in both works. Ralph van Raat falls between the two; closer to Hamelin but slightly heavier and the individual notes slightly less defined. Especially in the “Blues”, this undermines the feeling of being stuck in that factory, a cotton gin in overdrive, but it doesn’t undermine Raat’s recording. I prefer Hamelin, but given Naxos’ price advantage over Hyperion and the recording’s fine acoustic (the reverberation of the resonating strings is superbly caught), Raat remains perfectly competitive and a great introduction to those who wish to poke in and see what Rzewski’s compositions are all about. The beautiful 7-CD box (Nonesuch) of Rzewski playing his own compositions seems to be out of print, but the mp3 version is still available.

For Your Consideration: 'Free Men'

The French director and screenwriter Ismaël Ferroukhi, who was born in Morocco, had a breakthrough with his first major feature, Le Grand Voyage, in 2004, winning the Leone del Futuro prize for best first-time filmmaker at the Mostra Biennale in Venice. He co-wrote his new film, released in France as Les hommes libres, with screenwriter Alain-Michel Blanc and input from two historians, Benjamin Stora and Pascal Le Pautremat. It is a melancholy little movie set in the North African quarter of Paris, which follows the story of Muslims associated with the Grande Mosquée de Paris during the Nazi occupation of Paris. Having come to France as workers in the 1920s and 30s, these men and women are trapped in Paris during the occupation, and their earlier participation in labor unions has given them a taste for their own freedom. They hide those running from the Nazis, including North African Jewish families (some of the children hidden at the mosque have spoken about their experiences there), and they become involved in the French Resistance.

Most of the characters in the film are based on real people, although the details of the story are not necessarily historical. At the center is Younès, a young man just trying to make his own way who gets swept into a moral struggle greater than him -- created as a composite of several such men in Paris at the time. The role sits somewhat uneasily on the shoulders of Tahar Rahim (A Prophet), who does not seem able to show the full range of emotion the part demands, or perhaps by aiming too much toward subtlety the performance lacks much nuance. The same is true in some ways of another young actor, Mahmoud Shalaby, who plays Salim Halali, a young singer of Arabic songs who happens to be Jewish. The officials at the mosque have been creating false identity documents to pass off Jews as Muslims, a ploy that ultimately saves the singer's life.


Other Reviews:

New York Times | Los Angeles Times | Village Voice
Le Figaro | Washington Post | Movie Review Intelligence

At the center of these activities is Si Kaddour Ben Ghabrit, a representative of the Sultan of Morocco in Paris and the founder of the Institut Musulman at the Grande Mosquée de Paris. He is brought to life with the usual grace and subtlety by Michael Lonsdale, who told an interviewer that Ben Ghabrit was a friend of his family (although he was too young to have met him, his aunts, who had been raised in colonial families in Algeria, used to smoke hashish, not illegal then, with him.) With this fine performance, Lonsdale continues to work his way through the world religions, having already played a Benedictine abbot (The Name of the Rose, a Trappist monk (Of Gods and Men), and a devotee of Japanese samurai (Ronin). What makes the film so watchable is the evocation of occupied Paris (cinematography by Jérôme Alméras) -- and a part of that city's history that remains largely unknown. Set design (Catherine Jarrier-Prieur) and costumes (Virginie Montel) are beautiful and detailed, although the scenes in the mosque were shot, not in the Grande Mosquée de Paris, which is a sacred space, but on location in Morocco, at a gorgeous palace in Rabat. The story ranges widely, perhaps too widely, for its hour and a half: workers' rights, the French Resistance, Algerian and Moroccan hopes for independence. It is best just to let yourself be submerged in the cultural milieu, swept along by the beautiful score of North African and Andalusian traditional music, composed by Armand Amar and sung by Pinhas Cohen.

This film opens today in Washington, D.C., exclusively at Landmark's E Street Cinema.

3.5.12

The 1930s Club of Defiance: Soviet Harmonies

The 1930s Club of Defiance: Soviet Harmonies

In Soviet music—itself the result of the grim politico-cultural reality of the 20th century—Dmitry Shostakovich was the towering figure that no composer could easily escape. Looming was also the state and with it the constrictions on what could be written and what could not be written. No important composers from that period could avoid becoming a victim of censorship, or self-censorship, our outright suppression. Among them are Sofia Gubaidulina (1931, Christopol), Alfred Schnittke (1934, Engels near Saratov), Giya Kancheli (1935, Tbilisi), Arvo Pärt (1935, Paide), Valentin Silvestrov (1937, Kiev), and Tigran Mansurian (1939, Beirut).

Religion played a role in their various turns from the musical avant-garde to a language more consonant with most audiences’ idea of beauty. Faith provided meaning in a state that had systematically undermined concepts like truth, value, and indeed ‘meaning’, and it provided courage. That, and doubtlessly a sense of estrangement in a Russia-centric state that forcefully tried to downplay cultural heterogeneity, factored in. It isn’t likely mere coincidence that all the above named composers were minorities in Soviet Russia: Gubaidulina is of Tartar descent, Alfred Schnittke had Jewish-German-Russian background, Giya Kancheli is Georgian, Arvo Pärt Estonian, Valentin Silvestrov Ukrainian, and Tigran Mansurian Armenian.

Eventually these composers found their way out of the politico-cultural trap—either through ‘inner immigration’, actual immigration, musical sublimation, or quiet defiance, or any combination thereof. Their musical styles are wildly different from each other, but they have in common a rejection (explicit or not) of both, Western avant-garde and ‘Soviet socialist realist’ music – the latter in any case a deliberately vague political tool more than a stylistic guide. This undercurrent of defiance and beauty is the unifying force as each answered the challenges they encountered in their very different ways.

Sofia Gubaidulina answered with much silence, Bach, and rocky, craggy shreds and scraps of sound—deeply spiritual in her own way, but for the most part thorny for the uninitiated ears. Her music is howling, harsh, and yet serene.

Schnittke answered with absurdity, humor (irony), mischief, seduction, and complete independence. “Polystylistics” is what Schnittke called his style of wild and rambunctious neo-everything. A professor at Juilliard said so much differently, sneering at the mere mention of the name: “Schnittke, that trash can of music”. It could also have been a compliment. Schnittke picks up all that interests him on the cutting room floor of Western music and reassembles it in his image. It’s as if a waxen mold of a familiar shape had been sitting on a still-hot stove top, and become not so much molten but oddly, subversively askew now. Or as he said of himself: “I set down a beautiful chord, and it rusts.” He first raises, then defies your expectations… a technique Joseph Haydn was a grandmaster in, in his time. Among the best examples of Schnittke’s keen sense for combining ancient structures and harmonies with everything that has sounded between Monteverdi and now, are his six Concerti Grossi—a form not served since the high baroque.

Arvo Pärt answered with the most ostensibly religious defiance (“Credo in Jesum Christum”, 1968). His superficially simple, very simply gorgeous, spiritual minimalist music struck, as it were, a chord with audiences, especially in the West, where the inventive Munich record label ECM devoted itself to his music and was rewarded with a sales second only to when they hit gold with their Keith Jarrett recordings.

Silvestrov was considered a leading representative of the „Kiev avant-garde," completely at odds with the prevalent Soviet musical aesthetic and therefore the officials. Successful performances in the West – and honorable mention in Ulrich Dibelius’ German standard on modern music “Moderne Musik Nach 1945”– didn’t help to endear the young composer to the apparatchiks.

When Silvestrov gradually yet radically switched styles—from conventional dodecaphony via avant-gardism to his ‘metaphorical style’ with a strong mystic bent, also dubbed “new traditionalism” or “neo-romantic”—that too didn’t sit well with the official guardians of musical style. Said Dibelius, in a later revision of his book, slagged Silvestrov off as a “regressive ‘mystical’ poet” when only a few years earlier he had still been a promising “serial-progressive”. (It is not known, but reasonable to assume, that Dibelius got ekzema at the mere thought of C Major or B Minor.) In the Western musicological world his turn from avant-gardism was considered a turn from art to tosh.

Silvestrov started composing in a style saturated with musical reminiscence. One of his foremost tools is simplicity but not (though the accusation has been made,) banality. The style certainly resonated with audiences. Sofia Gubaidulina wrote about Silvestrov: “People will say his musical language is too simple. But this simplicity is deceiving. It contains a wonderful depth. And this simplicity is truly new – it is a new musical language.” The record company ECM (again) thought so too, and recordings of Silvestrov’s music have done the label well and spread Silvestrov’s music near and far… perhaps nearly as much as did Gidon Kremer. Also not a Russian but a Latvian and also forced to seek exile in Germany (like Pärt, Schnittke, Gubaidulina)—his importance for all these composers cannot be overstated. Many of Silvestrov’s works are dedicated to Kremer and/or were premiered, recorded, and continuously championed by him.


Paradisi gloria


available at Amazon
Paradisi gloria (Cruxient, Doderer, Kühr, Wozny)
U.Schirmer / MRSO, BR Chorus
BR Klassik

available at Amazon
Silvestrov, Bagatellen & Serenaden,
A.Lubimov
ECM

available at Amazon
Silvestrov, Requiem for Larissa,
V.Sirenko / Ukrainian NSO
ECM

available at Amazon
Silvestrov, Dedication, Post scriptum,
G.Kremer, R.Kaufman, V.Sacharov / MPhil
Apex

available at Amazon
Silvestrov, "Nosthalgia" (Piano Works),
Jenny Lin
Hässler
The Munich Radio Symphony Orchestra, not to be mistaken for either the Bavarian RSO (Mariss Jansons) or the Munich Symphonic Orchestra (Georg Schmöhe / Philippe Entremont), is easily overlooked in Munich, being the fifth among the six professional, proper-sized orchestras of the Bavarian capital. (The MPhil, Bavarian State Orchestra [the opera orchestra], and the Munich Chamber Orchestra [MKO] are the others.) The key to making a mark in an increasingly tough culture market as a second tier organization is to be different, more intelligent, more daring, and more flexible than the big boys in town. The MKO has created the local template for that, and the Munich RSO is doing that, too, branching out into both the educational and ‘rarified’ direction. The latter is exemplified by their series “Paradisi gloria”, which consists of secular music of the 20th and 21st century, performed in the wonderful, fittingly modern, catholic Herz-Jesu (of the Sacred Heart) Church—one of Munich’s few modern architecture gems.

The programmed music is often challenging, but with the prevalent conservative musical taste in Munich well covered by other bands, those in search of wider musical horizons eventually find the MRSO’s series. The response to Paradisi gloria, in any case, is enthusiastic and loyal. Peteris Vasks, Arvo Pärt, John Taverner, Morton Feldman, Alan Hovhaness, Tōru Takemitsu and the like are already the traditional elements on these programs, enriched by commissioned contemporary, or otherwise less well known works. A CD with these new commissions from the 2009/10 season was issued by BR Klassik late in 2010.


Silvestrov in Concert

The program on June 17th (2011) consisted of Valentin Silvestrov (hence the lengthy introduction above), featuring “Two Dialogues with Epilogue” and the “Requiem for Larissa”, written after the death of his wife. “Two Dialogues”–between Schubert and Wagner—is first a gorgeous, melancholic meditation on the “Kupelwieser-Walzer”, said to be by Schubert, but only orally passed on until finally written down by Richard Strauss in 1943. In the second part it works off a theme in A-flat that Wagner jotted down around 1858 (WWV 93). The strings heave throughout to the strung-along Wagner theme, swelling and receding like the sea visiting and leaving the shore. The whole string apparatus is eventually interrupted by (possibly ominous) tremolos played by the pianist directly—with two fingers of each hand—on the strings of his instrument. The Epilogue, dedicated to Pärt, alludes to something that must have been, or happened, before the music even started – and thus pre-flects a sense of ambiguity on the beginning of the entire work. Emblematic of Silvestrov’s music, and particularly notable here, is his focus reflection, harmonic vibration; response and reaction; the shadow or impression or echo of a thing, a theme, a topic, but never the thing itself.

A short but pretentious reading of Rainer Maria Rilke’s “Requiem für eine Freundin” bridged (or rather: interrupted) the concert before it continued with the “Requiem for Larissa”. The requiem consists of music itself consisting of echos and fragments, blocks, bleakness, entrancing sameness and timeless calm. Artificial reverb from the synthesizer creates a feeling of distance (Silvestrov’s audialization of memory) that mingles with the already reverberant brass and lulls the senses. The ever-impeccable BR Chorus, occasionally instructed just to hum, provided a tapestry above which soloists from within its ranks emerged and receded. The Requiem has much going for itself, just not brevity. Repetitiveness, even of beauty, can become tiresome, and while certain minimalist pieces might require the run-up and sheer length to establish the desired effect (think Einstein on the Beach), there is nothing in this music that suggests that the Requiem couldn’t be as (or more) effective and touching if it were a little shorter. (Unless, of course, the desired effect were fatigue.) In that sense the work is better suited for private listening with a Scotch and Soda nearby and a comfortable chair, rather than hard church benches, to sit in.

Andres Mustonen from Tallinn, founder of Hortus Musicus, is especially at home in early and contemporary music, and while he looked like he had just come from a yoga seminar—with his red scarf, long gray hair put up in a tulip bun on his head, and a fluffy black smock that could have doubled as sweatpants—he was truly the spiritus rector of the excellent performance.

Louis Schwizgebel Returns

Style masthead

Charles T. Downey, Louis Schwizgebel at the Terrace Theater
Washington Post, May 3, 2012

available at Amazon
Mendelssohn / Moszkowski / Mozart / Schulhoff, L. Schwizgebel-Wang

(Pan Classics)
How much can an artist grow musically in five years? When pianist Louis Schwizgebel won first prize in the Young Concert Artists International Auditions, in 2007, he (then styling his last name Schwizgebel-Wang) was introduced to Washington listeners in a recital at the Kennedy Center. On Tuesday night, YCA brought Schwizgebel, currently pursuing advanced studies at Juilliard, back to the Terrace Theater.

Schwizgebel, now 24, still played with fiery technical assurance, and he was willing to sacrifice some flashy acrobatics to emphasize coloristic effects, instead. His best efforts came in two arch-romantic works, especially a dreamy performance of the “Vallee d’Obermann” episode from the first book of Liszt’s “Annees de Pelerinage,” played with an operatic sense of scenography, both misty-eyed and irascibly dramatic. Those cinematographic instincts served him well in three Liszt arrangements of Schubert songs, especially “Der Erlkoenig.” [Continue reading]
Louis Schwizgebel, piano
Young Concert Artists
Kennedy Center Terrace Theater

SEE ALSO:
Cecelia Porter, Louis Schwizgebel-Wang (Washington Post, November 8, 2007)

Steve Smith, Classical Flair With Vernacular Flourishes (New York Times, November 16, 2007)

Bob Briggs, Louis Schwizgebel-Wang at the Wigmore Hall (Seen and Heard International, September 22, 2008)

2.5.12

Classical Music Agenda (May 2012)

This is the last month with a full schedule of classical music performances for Washington, before the summer doldrums start to set in. For the summer, we will have a rundown of some of best festivals to travel to, but for now here are the ten most intriguing options for concerts to hear in the Washington area this month. For the complete schedule, follow the Calendar bar on the right side of the page.

available at Amazon
Rameau, Keyboard Suites, A. Hewitt


available at Amazon
Couperin, Keyboard Music, Vol. 1, A. Hewitt
SOMETHING OLD:
If you have never heard of the music of Jan Dismas Zelenka (1679-1745), it is no surprise. He was a successful Bohemian composer, but his music, like so much from the Baroque era, has been largely forgotten. This Saturday's performance of Zelenka's set of five Capriccios, by the Bach Sinfonia at Silver Spring's Cultural Arts Center (May 5, 8 pm), will be the first one heard in North America. Horn players R. J. Kelley and Alexandra Cook will do the honors on the solo parts. Tickets: $30.

This is the weekend for Baroque music, because Angela Hewitt will be performing in the area, at Baltimore's Shriver Hall (May 6, 5:30 pm). This is her first local concert since 2009, and she will be playing music of Rameau, Couperin, and Bach. Tickets: $38.

SOMETHING NEW:
One of the best things that the Phillips Collection does is host a series of lectures and performances devoted to living composers. Next week, the museum has invited Dutch composer Michel van der Aa (b. 1970) to Washington: he will give an interactive talk about his theater works (May 9, 6 pm) and will also be present when members of the International Contemporary Ensemble perform some of his music (May 10, 6 pm). Tickets: $20.

SOMETHING SUNG:
For opera this month, our pick is the second performance of the Washington Concert Opera. It's not a rare opera or anything -- Saint-Saëns' Samson et Dalila (May 13, 6 pm) at Lisner Auditorium -- but we are looking forward to hearing Michelle DeYoung again. Tickets: $40 to $100.


The Debussy sesquicentennial is this year (born August 22, 1862), and the National Philharmonic is celebrating with the first-ever area performance of the composer's incidental music for the mystery play Le martyre de Saint Sébastien (May 19, 8 pm) in the Music Center at Strathmore. Tickets: $32 to $79.

In something much more traditional, we cannot pass up the chance to hear Bruckner's Te Deum, which will be given a relatively rare performance this month by the Baltimore Symphony Orchestra (May 24 and 25 in Baltimore, May 26 at Strathmore). Peter Oundjian conducts the Baltimore Choral Arts Society, and it seems beyond cruel to the singers to pair the work with Beethoven's ninth symphony: fortunately, the Bruckner is scheduled first. Tickets: $34 to $98.

Speaking of voices we want to hear, bass-baritone Gidon Saks will give the final recital of the season for Vocal Arts D.C. -- May 30, 7:30 pm, in the Kennedy Center Terrace Theater. Roger Vignoles will accompany a program of Handel, Shostakovich, Finzi, Musto, and Ibert. As shown in his turn as a venomous Hagen in Washington National Opera's concert performance of Götterdämmerung a couple years ago, Saks is a singer with a natural dramatic sense. Tickets: $45.

SOMETHING PLAYED:
We have been quite pleased with the mini-tenure of Charles Dutoit, who has guided the Philadelphia Orchestra through a rocky period of leaderlessness and bankruptcy. Many listeners are excited for the new music director, Yannick Nézet-Séguin, who will take the reins this fall, but we are rather sad to see Dutoit go. We would not miss one more chance to hear him lead this fabled ensemble, when they come to the Music Center at Strathmore (May 11, 8 pm), presented by Washington Performing Arts Society. The program includes Shostakovich's fifth symphony, Debussy's Prelude to the Afternoon of a Faun, and James Ehnes as soloist in Mendelssohn's ever-present violin concerto. Tickets: $40 to $105.

Another soloist we always want to hear, pianist Nelson Freire, makes his debut with the National Symphony Orchestra (May 17 to 19) at the Kennedy Center this month, playing the second Brahms piano concerto. Guest conductor Andreas Delfs will also lead a program of rarities, Haydn's Symphony No. 83 ("The Hen") and the second symphony by Kurt Weill. Tickets: $20 to $85.

SOMETHING DANCED:
Ballet with live music played by an orchestra rounds out our recommendations this month, with the visit of the Bolshoi Ballet (May 29 to June 3, in the Kennedy Center Opera House). They will perform the company's classic production of Coppélia (choreography by Marius Petipa and Enrico Cecchetti, updated by Sergei Vikharev). The Kennedy Center Opera House Orchestra will play the gorgeous score by Léo Delibes, and Bolshoi star Nina Kaptsova will play the lead role, Swanilda, who figures out the mystery of the curious daughter of a toymaker (for only three of the scheduled performances). Tickets: $29 to $115.

1.5.12

Ionarts-at-Large: Grieg in Heels, Sibelius in Dire Straits

Played by the Munich Philharmonic under Paavo Järvi on a Sunday morning, Benjamin Britten’s “Simple Symphony” op.4 for string orchestra sounded like a big blob of music. For one, it doesn’t strike me as a piece well suited for the character of the orchestra. An agile, edgy chamber orchestra might just salvage this youthful clunker written for student orchestra, but that’s not a style the Philharmonic can easily emulate at their best, much less so ante meridiem. And so the Simple Symphony sounded as tired as the alliterative movement titles: “Boisterous Bourrée”, “Playful Pizzicato”, “Sentimental Sarabande”, and “Frolicsome Finale”. Really? “Frolicsome Finale”? Let me have a go at it: At least the superficial sweetness of the serene slow movement, and Britten’s humble honesty about his recycled rhapsody of a school suite clumsily cobbled from drafts dating a dozen years back were enjoyable enough.

At a couple of minutes, the Simply Symphony might be pleasant; as it is, it lasts trice as long as the music it contains. For all the disappointment, there was the glimmer of hope that Paavo Järvi had chosen this piece so that he might have more time to rehearse Sibelius’ First Symphony. Perhaps so, but the performance did not suggest it.

Since World War II, continental Europe is a Sibelian wasteland. Especially in the German musical realm Sibelius is ignored—in good part due to the particularly ignorant diatribes of Theodor Adorno (with René Leibowitz as his footman). For all the classical music glories of the region, those persistent, dogged areas of ignorance are hard to fathom and harder still to excuse. The argument for Sibelius as (one of) the greatest symphonist(s) since Beethoven would fall on deaf (at best bemused) ears in the countries he has been written about as an “amateurish” proponent of the “asceticism of impotence” (Adorno) or outright “le plus mauvais compositeur du monde” (Leibowitz).


available at Amazon
J.Sibelius, Symphonies 1 & 3,
P.Inkinen, New Zealand SO
Naxos

The ability to play and listen to Sibelius has declined precipitously in continental Europe, with only a few islands of Sibelius reception exceptions probing this rule. Karajan made a few, limited but excellent, forays into Sibelius territory in Berlin, as did the Russian-educated Commander of the Order of the British Empire Kurt Sanderling. Lorin Maazel recorded an excellent symphony cycle with the Vienna Philharmonic in the late 60s. Those aside, there is not a continental European orchestra to be found among the 28 that have recorded the Sibelius symphonies. Sibelius is a Anglo-Nordic affair and unless Simon Rattle in Berlin or Jukka-Pekka Saraste in Cologne do something about it, one has to wait for guest conductors to bring the composer to German orchestras… and hope for the best.

Paavo Järvi and the Munich Philharmonic might have justified some of that hope, with a performance that occasionally hinted at the promise of idiomatic Sibelius. But the audience wouldn’t have it. From the first notes of the cough-riddled clarinet solo – sultry and soft as butter courtesy Alexandra Gruber – the audience proved inattentive, unwilling or incapable of getting into that spellbinding element, that Nordic vortex of Sibelius’ stark and gently searing world. Earlier leavers, exit alarms (or else the loudest haywire hearing aid ever), and an attention-grabbing case of fainting did their best to keep Sibelius at the fringe; excited but shrill violins, slipshod ensemble work, and a distinct lack of that staggered, nebulous depth, the insinuations and allegories of notes so typical for Sibelius did the rest. If Sibelius barely survived, it wasn’t for lack of loudness, though – Järvi happily cranked the orchestra up to 11.

Where other young pianists use the “I-can’t-pedal-in-heels” excuse to appear barefoot (because it’s an either-or, apparently), Khatia Buniatishvili seems to attempt to prove the opposite, pedaling her way through the Grieg Piano Concerto in 8 inch heels. Whose point was made by her performance is hard to say. The heavy romantic approach to Grieg as ‘Rachmaninoff-for-smaller-hands’ checked all the expectation-boxes of the romantic piano concerto, but my tastes must have moved on, as I was all the more reminded of how wonderful Rudolf Buchbinder performed the same concerto with the same orchestra (under Christian Thielemann) three years ago: With classical cool and near-Mozartean lightness. In the first movement Buniatishvili favored enthusiasm over accuracy. Her lusciousness was put to gorgeous effect in the Adagio, and her pianissimos in the third movement – in danger of being drowned out as they were – showed that she has something to say in every dynamic range. The encore – Liszt’s third Liebestraum – fit the slightly unimaginative romantic bill… too much, too heavy, too sweet so early in the day.

Give Me Ink!

Printmaking is alive and well! The death of paper has yet to happen. According to a discussion this past Sunday at the Baltimore Museum of Art by the guys who run the Printeresting website, R.L Tillman, Amze Evans, and Jason Urban -- kind of the Manny, Moe, and Jack of all things happening in the printed matter genre -- there is a renaissance going on. From Shepard Fairey's Obama Hope poster of the '08 election, the intense banners and signage from the Arab Spring surging through the Middle East, or the Occupy movement -- even giving some hip status to commercial venues such as Anthropology and Levis.

Artists have so many relatively inexpensive possibilities ready for exploitation: woodblock, digital, offset, Kinkos, Staples, or hand squeegeed. Producing fine art limited editions selling for thousands or social statements wheat pasted onto walls and phone poles, printed matter is diverse, democratizing, and thriving.


I've often mentioned my love of ink pressed onto paper, especially if you are lucky enough to have experienced the visceral quality, the smell, as the press rolls over the plate and the paper is peeled away, revealing the outcome for the first time -- it's magic. I first experienced it as a paperboy, watching the huge rolls of blank white newsprint get spun into the NEWS I would deliver.

I later worked in a textile mill where the rolls of paper were replaced with cotton fabric. Instead of current events, the massive machines spewed miles of 4- to 15-color intricate designs onto the fabric. The cloth would later become clothing, bedding or almost anything, a different magic but every bit as mesmerizing.


The Printeresting talk was part of the annual Baltimore Contemporary Print Fair at the Baltimore Museum of Art. A three-day love fest of all things printmaking. There were lectures, parties, and some 20 presses from around the country set up in the BMA's second-floor galleries offering some very good deals on a wide range of printing styles and mediums. New to medium, a seasoned collector, or browser -- the event has something for most everyone. Also in conjunction with the fair there were exhibits at area galleries -- C. Grimaldis and Nudashank -- and a book art mini-fair at Open Space. I have more pictures on my Flickr page.

If you could not attend the fair, there is still an opportunity to purchase a very nice print: "YU, MICA, ME" by artist Trenton Doyle Hancock. The proceeds will be split between the BMA acquisition fund for contemporary prints and MICA's Globe Fund to support artists' residencies. The print was made using the old Baltimore landmark Globe Press's iconic poster style and wood type.

(Swoon image courtesy of Black Heart Press)