CD Reviews | CTD (Briefly Noted) | JFL (Dip Your Ears) | DVD Reviews

19.12.06

Shostakovich in 2006, Part 3

available at Amazon
Shostakovich, The Golden Age (complete ballet), Royal Scottish National Orchestra, José Serebrier (released on November 21, 2006)
If The Golden Age, a ballet produced at the State Academic Theater in Leningrad (St. Petersburg's Mariinsky Theater) in 1930, was a failure it was not because of Shostakovich's score. Excerpts of the music were included in later ballets, a suite based on the ballet, and piano versions made for the Ballet Suites collection. Although not the first (but the most recent and the cheapest), this recording of the complete ballet has much to recommend it. It is based on the most accurate source for the original production, a piano score edited by Manashir Yabukov, reflecting what Shostakovich anointed as the final version of the score. Since the ballet was pronounced a failure by the Soviet authorities, later perceptions of the score were made through subsequent redactions. This recording also claims to observe all of the repeats indicated for the premiere performance.

The plot is an absurd tale, involving the visit of a Soviet soccer team to an unspecified Western city, identified only as U-Town. When the Mariinsky Ballet attempted to revive the ballet earlier this year, reviewed in its London performance by The Guardian, American choreographer Noah Gelber did his best to update the scenario, by casting the love story not as something that is happening right now but that is viewed historically. Fortunately with a CD recording, the listener's imagination can provide the choreography and scenario and one can merely focus on this side of Shostakovich's musical imagination, the acidic humor (the hysterical "Soviet Dance" in Act I is a manic Offenbach galop on steroids) and extravagantly coloristic orchestration (lots of saxophone, sneering brass glissandi, silly percussion, bumbling contrabassoon, and even a flexatone in Act I's "The Supposed Terrorist" and Act III's "Touching Coalition of the Classes, Slightly Fraudulent").

It is no secret that we at Ionarts are fans of Uruguayan-born conductor José Serebrier. With all of the jazz and popular idioms cheek and jowl with classical traditions, Serebrier brings vital energy throughout, not only in the grotesque waltzes and oompah band sections, but in slow movements like the luscious, tender Adagio "Dance of Diva," where the languorous soprano sax solo incarnates the tempting Western woman who eventually asks the leader of the Soviet team to dance with her. The RSNO's playing is uneven at times, for example not quite aligned at all points in "Foxtrot ... foxtrot ... foxtrot" (CD 1, track 19) -- speaking of which, is that the main theme of "Springtime for Hitler" somehow coiled inside this music? Where the conflict of capitalist and communist comes to a head, of course, is the Music Hall, the "divertissement" that opens the third act, with its jazzy Chechotka (Tap-dance), sultry Tango, famous Polka ("Once upon a Time in Geneva -- Angel of Peace"), and the most clattering, cataclysmic Can-Can that could be imagined. Bravo to Serebrier for the imagination behind the shaping of this sprawling, wandering score.

Naxos 8.570217-18

Go back to Part 2 / Part 1

18.12.06

Christmas with Chantry

Albrecht Dürer, Sackbut playersIn a round-up of holiday concerts in Washington, I singled out two for special praise, including Saturday night's concert by Chantry and the Orchestra of the 17th Century, in the lovely church of St. Mary Mother of God in Chinatown. It is in the same category as the Folger Consort's Christmas concert (on the docket for a review this week) because of the repertory. No carols, no Messiah, no Nutcracker, and yet Christmas. Real Christmas, too, not commercial Christmas: Basilica di San Pietro Dies natalis Christi (Palestrina's motet and imitation Mass Hodie Christus natus est), and Venice transplanted to Lutheran Germany Weihnacht (Schütz's Christmas Oratorio). Obviously proud, conductor David Taylor gave an over-lengthy introduction to each half, all the more unnecessary because his comments largely reprised the extensive program notes.

You are right to expect a certain musicologist to have been elated solely by the program. The musical results in performance were unfortunately uneven, but important marks go to Taylor and his forces for again bringing music of great interest to Washington. For whatever reason, the group's normally pure intonation did not lock in as effortlessly as it has in previous concerts. Thinking that it may have been my position in the sanctuary -- on one of the side aisles with the singers split into two choirs -- I moved to the back of the center aisle at intermission. Adding the less than solid playing of the instrumentalists in the Schütz did not help the situation, nor did the greater distance in the room. All pistons did not seem to be firing properly, but everyone has off nights.

Other Reviews:

Joan Reinthaler, Chantry's Nativity-Themed Program Is Well Shepherded (Washington Post, December 18)
This motet and Mass derived from it are one of Palestrina's relatively rare forays into the Venetian polychoral style. The strange way that he divides the forces, with all the treble voices in the first choir, created a strange lacuna at the top of the second choir. The altos on the right side, who should dominate, were just overwhelmed by the other voices, and the sopranos on the treble-heavy left side clashed more than they meshed, including something that went temporarily wrong in the middle of the Gloria. The interpolation of movements from a keyboard tablature Mass by Claudio Merulo, played beautifully on the portative organ by Adam Pearl, was effective, liturgically appropriate, and lovely.

In the Schütz, the lengthy narrative recitatives seemed wooden as performed by tenor Scott Williamson, whose timbre was on the baritone side of the male voice. In alternation with the storyline are aria moments for various solos or combinations. Nice moments were offered by the four alto shepherds, with the best instrumental playing of the evening (from recorders), and the four bass/baritone high priests and scribes, accompanied by sackbuts. All in all, it was an enjoyable but not excellent evening of music.

Chantry's next concert (March 24, 8 pm) in St. Mary Mother of God, offers music for Holy Week in Renaissance Rome, by Allegri, Gesualdo, Lotti, Palestrina, and Lassus.

Shostakovich in 2006, Part 2

available at Amazon
Shostakovich, Symphony No. 7, Orchestre National de France, Kurt Masur, Sarah Nemtanu (released on October 31, 2006)
Kurt Masur's handling of certain parts of the orchestral repertory is sometimes thought to lack poetry. Over the past year, health problems have caused other concerns, which were evident on his recent trip to Washington with the London Philharmonic. However, reports have reached my ears of his exceptional work with the Orchestre National de France (where he has been music director since 2002), particularly in his Mendelssohn cycle and, although it cannot yet be called a cycle, his work in Paris on the symphonies of Shostakovich. (Masur's Shostakovich was a highlight during his tenure with the New York Philharmonic, too.) Reviews of his Paris DSCH 5th in 2004 were raves, and when his illness last winter seemed to have scuttled his planned performance of the Leningrad Symphony, the ONF decided not to cancel or replace the conductor but to postpone the performance until Masur was well again.

It finally took place on May 18 at the Théâtre des Champs-Elysées, and this live recording captured the extraordinary result. Frank Cadenhead reviewed the concert for Musical America, published on May 26 (the review, Masur Conducts the 'Leningrad' in Paris, can be found on Masur's Web site). He said that the concert "set something of a gold standard, both for performances of the work and for the orchestra's level of accomplishment under this master musician." Christian Merlin also wrote a review (Une fresque saisissante, May 22) for Le Figaro (my translation):
The fact that Masur personally knew the composer and was familiar with Stalinism surely helped him penetrate the spirit of this music. It was not enough perhaps to lessen the sometimes tedious length of this monument, but it allowed him to give it a gripping dramatic intensity, at the edge of what can be sustained: the only way to accomplish the first movement's vertiginous crescendo, not merely an exercise in endurance but a nightmarish unfolding. As if on springs, Masur tapped his foot, made sounds, and his ONF musicians followed him as if a single person, at full bowing in the strings, at full power in the brass, at full incandescence in the percussion (the tireless Emmanuel Curt, on the snare drum).
The 7th symphony (op. 60) -- named the Leningrad because Shostakovich wrote most of the work while in that city during its siege by the Germany army -- is a gargantuan 75 minutes long, with the first movement close to half of that length. The first movement goes through 6 minutes of other identities, a broad, almost official opening, a slow section with solo flute that could be Debussy, before the insistent military march begins, with that same solo flute over insistent percussion. Often compared to Ravel's Bolero, the bulk of the movement is essentially one gesture over the course of over 15 minutes, a huge crescendo over an ostinato pattern, spinning out a single melodic idea. Jens has described his admiration of the Bernstein recording of the 7th symphony precisely because it has a ruthless sense of its military subject, if not necessarily propulsion (at 84 minutes, it is more drawn out than Masur's reading).

When the ONF played the Leningrad at the Proms in August, the London critics were not convinced, to say the least (as in The Guardian). Some listeners, including one Béla Bartók, simply do not care for the Leningrad Symphony. If you are not opposed to it, this recording is a thrilling live rendition, gutsy and on the edge, captured in excellent sound. As a sound document, it is also a tribute to Kurt Masur's career, especially his Shostakovich.

Naïve V 5071

Go to Part 1 / Part 3

17.12.06

Shostakovich in 2006, Part 1

Available at Amazon:
available at Amazon
Shostakovich, Violin and Cello Sonatas, Romance and Nocturne for Cello and Orchestra (from The Gadfly), D. Yablonsky, M. Fedotov, E. Saranceva, G. Petrova, Russian Philharmonic (released on October 31, 2006)
There must be someone out there who has not yet acquired some new discs this year to fill out the Shostakovich corner of his library. The Russian composer celebrated a centenary in 2006, and musicians everywhere have been giving concerts and releasing recordings of his music. These recordings offer some interesting vantage points on Dmitri Dmitrievich and could be nice acquisitions for the end of the Shostakovich year.

First, from Naxos an ensemble recording of works for cello and violin. The Cello Sonata, op. 40, dates from 1934, when the composer was in his late 20s, and he shows his roots quite clearly. One could almost mistake the first movement's opening section for Fauré, and the second movement for moody Schubert. He hews fairly closely to the traditional forms of the classical sonata. The performance is good, in spite of some strained passages from cellist Dmitry Yablonsky, especially in high parts with multiple stops. The tender slow movement is endlessly seductive. The Violin Sonata, op. 134, dates from 1968, and it is as barren, sparse, and enigmatic as the earlier work is lyrical. The performance, with violinist Maxim Fedotov and pianist Galina Petrova, often leans toward the pitiless and mechanical, which captures the bitterness of the score. True, neither of these sonatas really needs a new recording, but the performances have a convincing Russian character. Yablonsky's transcriptions of a romance and nocturne from Shostakovich's nifty score for The Gadfly, a pathetic propaganda film, are bon-bons guaranteed to rot your teeth, and they fill out this cross-sectional look at the composer's multi-faceted work.

Naxos 8.557722

Go to Part 2

In Brief

LinksHere is your regular Sunday dosage of interesting items, from Blogville and beyond:

  • Jessica Duchen has published an article about just what exactly an authentic performance of Handel's Messiah is. Do conductors and audience members have "Messianic delusions," as she her headline puts it? [The Independent]
  • As reported all over the place, Roberto Alagna was booed off the stage of La Scala this weekend. However, Giorgia Meschini had by far the best take on the story, by transforming it into a hilarious comic strip ("Panico alla Scala!!!"), with pictures from the opera house and Photoshopped (Italian) text balloons. My favorite is when Alagna, a French speaker, says "parbleu," a word that instantly marks someone as French in a comic book, even though I have never heard a French person actually say it. [No guru, no method, no teacher]
  • La Cieca surprises many and comes down in support of Alagna in LaScalaGate2006. It is a well-reasoned argument. [parterre box]
  • Steve Hicken quotes a recipe for "Eggs Carter" in honor of Elliot Carter's 98th birthday. [listen.]
  • Glimmerglass will mount the first American production of Wagner's little-known opera Das Liebesverbot. [AP]
  • Having spent some time doing extra work as an editor and proofreader, this comic from Geist, Lesser-Known Editing and Proofreading Marks, made me smile. This was pointed out by a favorite read, an always informative and entertaining, if slightly esoteric blog. [languagehat]
  • Bob Shingleton has a longish review of a new book about, or rather not about, the closeted skeletons in the House of Wagner. [On an Overgrown Path]
  • As predicted in some quarters, WETA's board has officially admitted that it will consider switching back from an all-news format to classical music, if WGMS goes to a sports format. If WETA does go back to classical music, I pledge to make nothing but overjoyed statements here, no smug "I-told-you-so" triumphalism. Promise. WETA, not only will you be making Ionarts happy, but the NEA will get off your back, too. [Washington Post]
  • On a list of the Top 51 Classical Music Blogs, compiled by Scott Spiegelberg, Ionarts comes in at #4. Watch out, Alex Ross (#1), Sequenza 21 (#2), and On an Overgrown Path (#3): you are in our crosshairs. [Musical Perceptions]

16.12.06

Marc Minkowski Releases

Since forming his historically informed performance (HIP) ensemble, Les Musiciens du Louvre, in the 1980s conductor Marc Minkowski has released a stunning number of excellent recordings, many of which have set the benchmark for performance of 17th- and 18th-century music. Quite naturally, the group has specialized in French composers of le grand siècle, although they have made excellent recordings of Handel operas, too, and recently a few forays into other territory, including Mozart and even Berlioz, Méhul, and Offenbach.

Available at Amazon:
available at Amazon
Rameau, Hippolyte et Aricie, Jean-Paul Fouchécourt, Véronique Gens, Bernarda Fink, Laurent Naouri, Les Musiciens du Louvre, Ensemble Vocal Sagittarius, Marc Minkowski (first released 1995, re-released September 2006)
Perhaps the best work that Minkowski and other French conductors, especially William Christie (an honorary citizen of France), have done is give the music of Jean-Philippe Rameau the recordings it deserves. Hippolyte et Aricie was the first major Rameau opera that Minkowski released, in this live recording made in June 1994 at the Opéra Royal in Versailles. Graham Sadler's work on the new critical edition of the works of Rameau has revealed the misconceptions, even fabrications, of the composer's operas and given us guidance on the multiple versions of most of them. In the excellent liner notes, including an essay by none other than Graham Sadler, Minkowski explains how he arrived at the rather complete form of the score recorded here, with some parts that have often been cut from Hippolyte restored. The dance music in this opera is so charming, like the sailors' ballet in Act III (in which we can hear the frenzied clicking of oboe machinery in one of the rigaudons), I would hate not to have it.

The vocal casting is superb, with Jean-Paul Fouchécourt and Véronique Gens in excellent voice as the eponymous lovers. Some of the music is just too good to believe, as in Aricie's opening aria of Act I ("Temple sacré"), which is luscious, gentle, seductive, and harmonically daring. Although some of the minor roles are merely good, Bernarda Fink has a superlative turn as Phèdre, the jealous stepmother (a review of her Sesto with René Jacobs in La Clemenza di Tito is forthcoming), and Laurent Naouri is appropriately solemn as the three gods, Pluton, Neptune, and Jupiter. There are some tracks that could have benefitted from an alternate take, if this were not a live recording. The thunder scene of Diana's anger in Act I, for example, is uneven, with the many runs jumbled by instruments and voices, but the booming percussion and thunder screen makes it thrilling. This set is certainly worth owning, especially since its only competition -- Les Arts Florissants with Mark Padmore and one Lorraine Hunt as Phèdre -- appears to be mostly unavailable in the United States (still carried by Amazon UK). Janet Baker's historic recording is a curiosity worth finding if you can.

available at Amazon
Lully, Acis et Galatée, Jean-Paul Fouchécourt, Véronique Gens, Mireille Delunsch, Howard Crook, Laurent Naouri, Les Musiciens du Louvre, Marc Minkowski (first released 1998, re-released September 12, 2006)
Opera Lafayette gave a live performance of Jean-Baptiste Lully's final opera, Acis et Galatée, here last year. For this 1996 live recording in the Salle Wagram in Paris, Minkowski reunited the two lead singers from Hippolyte et Aricie, with Fouchécourt and Gens singing equally well in these title roles, and Laurent Naouri again, in the memorable role of the cyclops, Polyphème. First released by Deutsche Grammophon in 1998, Archiv has recently given it a most welcome re-release. Fouchécourt has the sweetest high range, perfectly suited to this kind of music, and Gens gives a moving performance in the little scena in Act III, after Acis is fatally crushed by the rock thrown by the cyclops, in alternation with instrumental passages. The music, especially the chaconne and passacaille movements, is exquisite, Lully at the height of his craft. The instrumental performance here is equal to the vocal, with tight, rhythmically activated readings of all the dance pieces, often with the phrase shapes highlighted crisply by percussion.

Minkowski again shows his musicological connections, with the essay in this booklet by Jérôme de La Gorce (and English translations by Graham Sadler). If you are used to the serious tone of Lully's tragic operas, this work is in a lighter pastoral style, and in it, as La Gorce put it in his essay, Lully rediscovered shortly before his death the comic mode he had when he collaborated with Molière. The role of Polyphemus, sung with appropriate bluster and an odd accent by Naouri, is particularly funny: the Act II entrance of the cyclops is preceded by a heavy-footed march, which Minkowski has punctuated by a silly panpipe signal, almost like a slide whistle. Besides all of its strengths (there are not even any "live recording" glitches to be regretted here), this is the only complete recording of the opera, and it is worth owning.

available at Amazon
Rameau, Une symphonie imaginaire, Les Musiciens du Louvre, Marc Minkowski (released on June 14, 2005)
available at Amazon
Rameau, Les Boréades, Les Arts Florissants
Alex Ross praised Minkowski's most recent Rameau disc, Une symphonie imaginaire, when it was released and listed it on his Top 10 List of 2005 recordings. I missed the recording at the time, but it has recently crossed my desk and has become favorite listening, for either focused appreciation or background for cooking dinner. The concept is simple and ingenious: Rameau was universally praised for the symphonic pieces in his operas but wrote almost no stand-alone music for orchestra alone. Minkowski stitches together his imaginary Rameau symphony from various places, including a ritournelle from Hippolyte et Aricie, dance movements from several operas and ballets, and arias with the vocal parts artfully removed. One particularly beautiful example of the latter is "Tristes apprêts, pâles flambeaux" from Castor et Pollux, which recently appeared in an opera scene in Sofia Coppola's latest movie, Marie-Antoinette (sound taken from the excellent recording by Les Arts Florissants). There is even a modern orchestral transcription of Rameau's famous piece for keyboard, La Poule (The hen). Most satisfying are several pieces drawn from Les Boréades, a little-known tragic opera published posthumously. John Eliot Gardner has recorded it, but I am now most interested in seeing the DVD, released in 2004, of a performance of the opera in Paris by Les Arts Florissants, with Barbara Bonney and none other than Laurent Naouri again.

Archiv 445 853-2 / Archiv 453 497-2 / Archiv B0004478-02

15.12.06

Odd Mix of Goodies at the NSO

Other Reviews:

Daniel Ginsberg, NSO Makes the Most of a Thin Connection (Washington Post, December 15)
Ginastera – who pronounced his name with a soft, Italian “G” – is a composer who has suffered undue neglect since he died in 1983… and Maestro Slatkin is out to change that. Part of that was the programming of the Concerto for Strings, op. 33. Leonard Slatkin, who passionately believes in this work, was not able to program this concerto for some time – for fear that people would not come and give the work its chance to be heard. So he finally packaged it into a program certain to draw the audience to the Kennedy Center’s Concert Hall, Ginastera or not. The lure, musically or otherwise as unrelated to the Concerto for Strings as they are to each other –‘unrelatedness’ being a virtue (!) of good programming, according to Slatkin – in this run of performances are Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony and the Second Piano Concerto by Saint-Saëns.

available at ArkivMusic and Amazon
A.Ginastera, Concerto per corde op.33 et al., Orchestre de Lancy-Geneve / Sawicki
The Ginastera concerto opens with Variazioni per i Solisti, a movement dominated by the exchange between five soloists and the string section’s ‘Greek chorus’. A solo violin lament of serene nature achieved by sometimes abrasive means contrasts with soft-as-can-be two-note sighs among the strings. Then the solo and theme is passed around the principal strings: the cello (David Hardy) next, followed by the second violin (Marissa Regni), then viola (Daniel Foster), finally double bass (Robert Oppelt). Those in the audience who had to be convinced of the (great) merit of the work might have followed the first movement with curious lack of comprehension. Despite quartertone experiments its character is still resolutely tonal – mildly stretching the capacity for dissonance of conservative ears.

The second movement slowly creeps to a point of penetration of the open mind; playful and coy all along. The third movement Adagio angoscioso calmly gathers the energy it needs for release in the stunning Finale furioso - the only movement that is not derived from Ginastera’s Second String Quartet which served as the (much adapted) model for his op. 33. Indeed, there are plenty passages that sound like an orchestrated string quartet – with more than just a dose of Bartók here and there. Those above mentioned ‘conservative’ ears may, for all the work’s charm, fail to be won over upon first hearing… even after the finale, which should do the trick, though. A beast of fury, driving the music to a climax and near-breaking point with its irregular rhythms and sheer volume. Why the result was much more muted than expected – lack of enthusiasm on part of the conductor was certainly not the problem – I do not know. To hear the warm (if neither unanimous nor enthusiastic) reception it received, however, was heartening.

available at Amazon
Saint-Saëns, Piano Concertos, Hough / Orama


available at Amazon
Saint-Saëns, Piano Concertos, Roge / Dutoit
André Watts is a very familiar name to American audiences (and the audience in this region might know him from his years as artist in residence at the University of Maryland, not just his famed, prodigious youth) but has so far eluded my ears, both on record and in concert. Saint-Saëns’ Second Piano Concerto, op. 22, with the NSO put that omission right. Big, bold, and straight as an arrow – not only in the entry but throughout the concerto: Watts played in a manner with which neither flaw nor faults could be found. He played up the entertainment value here and there (entertainment is what this concerto is about, after all) – but also had a refreshing matter-of-fact touch to bring to it. All five Saint-Saëns piano concertos are nice to hear and worth exploring; none of them are bestowed with that nebulous label of “great,” though. One rides along on the surface of the prettiness and the stormy passages and the bubbles… but unless one is among the performers, the experience is a very passive one. Those who love the Ginastera might find the piano concerto to merely dabble along; those who raise an eyebrow at the Argentine’s concerto will likely embrace Watts and Saint-Saëns as the feel-good type of classical music they seek out.

available at Amazon
Abbado, BPh


available at ArkivMusic
Dausgaard, Swedish Ch.O.


available at Amazon
Vänskä, Minnesota
available at Amazon
Barenboim, Berlin Sta.Kap.


available at Amazon
Rattle, WPh


available at Amazon
Zinman, Zurich
Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony – “Beethoven’s version” this time… since Gustav Mahler’s (admittedly fairly minor) adjustments to the score were used the last time Leonard Slatkin conducted the Beethoven symphonies with the NSO. The Maestro, who was at the time harshly criticized in the Washington Post for his choice of the “Mahler versions” (somewhat beyond what the significance of that choice merited, in my opinion), defends that choice in the program notes (he may still feel the sting) and mentions the adjustments now made to the work; both in accordance with - and deviation from - the latest Jonathan Del Mar-edited Bärenreiter score. At least seven Beethoven cycles are by now based on this edition: Abbado/Berlin, Barenboim/BerlinStaatskapelle, Dausgaard/Swedish Chamber Orchestra, Haitink/LSO, Rattle/Vienna, Vanska/Minnesota, Zinman/Zurich. But even these conductors pick and choose what they do alter or do not alter, so when Slatkin brushes the hoopla around tempo or double-woodwind or taken or omitted repeats off with “there is really no need to go into more detail,” he may sound defensive but is absolutely correct. Or, as he grumbled at me, slightly annoyed, in an interview I recently had with him: “They are all ‘Beethoven-versions’!”

And Beethoven it was with the NSO: brisk, energetic, and ironfisted in the first movement, with deliberate delicacy, a dry gait in the second, temperately paced with subtlety in the third movement before that great release into the joyful sound that is the finale. Save for the third movement (Allegro), the whole affair was crisp, fast, but not hurried. The playing was very fine and amounted, in an understated way, to one of the best performances I have heard from the NSO under Slatkin this season.

The performance will be repeated tonight at 7PM and tomorrow, Saturday, at 8PM.

Critical Mozart

W. A. MozartRecently, Alex Ross hailed the opening of the Mozart Institute Web site, an online version of the Neue Mozart-Ausgabe. The idea is "to make Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart's musical compositions widely and conveniently accessible to the public, for personal study and for educational and classroom use." You can search for the part of the critical edition you want, download it, and print it out, as long as you "agree to use this web site only for personal study and not to make copies except for my personal use."

Who are they kidding? Theoretically this is no different than teachers and students of music photocopying parts of the critical edition scores for study and practice, which we do all the time in our music libraries. However, when you open that up to the Entire Freaking Internet, it is a totally new ball game. Predictably and, I think, justifiably, there was some concerned murmuring on the American Musicological Society's e-mail list about such an enterprise. Are the rights of the editors being protected under such an arrangement? Newspapers have reported that the International Mozart Foundation paid Bärenreiter-Verlag the sum of 302,000 € ($397,000) for the digital publication rights. To whom will that money go?

Since I have not edited any of the volumes in the NMA, I am ecstatically downloading everything I can manage, although the site is overrun with requests. However, if that were my work -- not only the carefully checked scores but the extensive critical notes -- available to the whole world for free instead of buying it in legitimate book form, I would probably be upset.