The National Symphony Orchestra’s series of concerts this week might have gone even more unnoticed with its nameless protagonists and unexciting programming. Verdi’s La forza del destino overture, Saint-Saëns’ Third Violin Concerto, and Tchaikovsky’s Fifth Symphony are not exactly barnstormers; not the kind of programming that kindles fervor in regular concert-goers.
Chee-Yun, the violinist, is just another pretty face / face-less Asian fiddler (as a visiting professor at the University of Indiana there is a Slatkin-link, though); Manfred Honeck would be completely unknown in these parts of town had he not just been named the new music director at Pittsburgh, one of the best orchestras of the country.
This ends the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra’s misguided and expectedly failed experiment of having three roving conductors at the helm… as if three B-list conductors together might amount to the name recognition, status, or quality musical leadership that one A-list maestro might. (The overrated Andrew “Not Colin” Davis, the steady, reliable, reliably unexciting Yan Pascal Tortelier, and the underrated, insider-beloved Marek Janowski made up this troika that was allowed to waste precious years of distinct musical direction after one of the best conductors in the world, Mariss Jansons, stepped down in 2004.)
Now Manfred Honeck, who immediately reminds of Franz Welser-Möst (Cleveland’s mildly controversial custodian of quality music-making) in nationality, background, and even looks, will hopefully continue where the sublime Latvian left off. His performance in Washington on Thursday was not as telling about where he might take the bigger orchestra to the north… Verdi’s overture was driven, muscular, determined, and compact but surely not overly polished.
Robert Battey, A Lasting First Impression (Washington Post, February 3)
A musical shot of insulin would have been appropriate for the second half. Instead: Tchaikovsky “Five”; itself sufficient to induce symphony-diabetes. As it was, the Tchaikovsky turned out to be the finest performance: Deliberate, heaving like a dying beast, with dark clouds before the musical story-telling picks up with brighter, more animated rhythms. Slowly awaking was the second movement, much like film music, in the best sense. The finale, finally, was not too weighty, not choked by its own portentousness and even light and foot-tappingly moving forward during the Allegro vivace.
Today's performance will take place at 1.30PM, the performance on Saturday at 8PM.